North Star Group, Inc.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
RAIN GARDENS FOR SERENITY VILLAGE
Integrating Stormwater Management and Edible Landscaping in Mobile, Alabama
An Integrated Approach to Affordable Housing, Green Infrastructure, and Community
Revitalization
Table of Contents
1. Executive Summary and Preamble
2. Introduction
2.1. Project Overview and Vision
2.2. Objectives and Scope
3. Site Context and Soil Analysis
3.1. Overview of the 39Acre Site
3.2. Natural Topography and Existing Grading
3.3. Soil Resource Analysis (Focus on BuC Soils)
4. Stormwater Management and Overflow Design
4.1. Current Stormwater Challenges in Mobile
4.2. Design of a Central Drainage Pond and Integrated Rain Garden
4.3. Overflow Management: Calculations and Safety Considerations
5. Edible Rain Garden Design for Food Production
5.1. Caloric Yield Objectives and Target Outputs
5.2. Crop Selection, Yield Data, and Companion Planting Strategies
5.3. Area Requirements: Balancing Infiltration and Food Production
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
1
6. Integration with Broader Development Goals
6.1. Transit-Oriented Development and Connectivity
6.2. Economic Benefits and Cost Savings
6.3. Potential Job Creation and Community Empowerment
7. Microclimate, Shade, and Passive Cooling Strategies
7.1. Addressing Mobile’s Climate
7.2. Passive Cooling and Shade Design Proposals
8. Economic Impact and Cost-Savings Analysis
8.1. Comparison: Grey vs. Green Infrastructure
8.2. Reuse of Existing Grading
8.3. Broader Municipal Savings
9. Technical Appendix
9.1. Stormwater Volume and Infiltration Calculations
9.2. Caloric Production and Yield Estimates
9.3. Schematic Diagrams, Tables, and MATLAB Plot Excerpts
10. Conclusions and Recommendations
11. References and Appendices
Appendix A: Detailed Yield and Caloric Conversion Tables
Appendix B: Full Stormwater Volume and Infiltration Calculation Sheets
Appendix C: Schematic Diagrams and MATLAB Plot Excerpts
Appendix D: Economic Analysis Tables and Cost Comparison Breakdown
Appendix E: Additional Technical Notes and Assumptions
1. Executive Summary and Preamble
Serenity Village is envisioned as a transformative affordable housing development on a 39acre
parcel adjacent to Three Mile Creek in Mobile, Alabama. Given Mobile’s status as one of the
wettest cities in the United States—with an average annual rainfall of about 66 inches—and its
chronic flooding challenges, this project integrates a centrally located drainage pond with an
edible rain garden system to serve dual purposes:
Stormwater Management: The central drainage pond is designed to capture and retain
runoff from all impervious surfaces on the developable portion of the site, ensuring that
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
2
additional flow does not exceed the current conditions into Three Mile Creek. Overflow is
safely controlled via regulated outlets that interface with the existing municipal drainage
system.
Edible Production: The rain garden also functions as a productive vegetable garden. It is
designed to supply up to 600 calories per day per resident (about 30% of a 2,000-calorie
diet), thus providing a supplemental source of nutrition and an opportunity for local food
production.
Economic Efficiency and Community Revitalization: By replacing traditional “grey”
infrastructure with an integrated green system, the development can significantly reduce
both construction and maintenance costs. In addition, the system is aligned with a
broader Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) strategy that connects residents to the
nearby Medical Center, and it holds the potential for ancillary employment—such as roles
for foster youth transitioning from care.
This white paper presents both a user-facing narrative for decision-makers and community
stakeholders as well as a technical appendix containing detailed calculations, tables, and
schematic diagrams to support the engineering design.
2. Introduction
2.1. Project Overview and Vision
Serenity Village represents an innovative approach to affordable housing that combines
highquality modular construction with integrated green infrastructure. The development is
located on a 39acre site in the Three Mile Creek region of Mobile, Alabama, and aims to:
Mitigate Stormwater Runoff: Through a central drainage pond and integrated edible rain
gardens that capture runoff from roofs, parking areas, and other impervious surfaces.
Generate Edible Yields: By producing approximately 600 calories per day per resident
through high-yield crops (e.g., potatoes, sweet potatoes, corn, and legumes), contributing
to local food security.
Reduce Infrastructure Costs: Lower capital and maintenance expenses relative to
conventional stormwater systems.
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
3
Support Broader Community Goals: Through enhanced connectivity (TOD) with the
nearby Medical Center and potential job creation, particularly for vulnerable groups such
as foster youth transitioning out of care.
2.2. Objectives and Scope
The primary objectives are to:
Control Stormwater: Ensure that runoff from the development is managed on-site so that
Three Mile Creek’s flow remains unaffected.
Produce Food: Allocate sufficient area per housing unit to produce an estimated 600
calories per day for each resident.
Leverage Natural Topography: Utilize the existing site grading (elevations from
approximately 30 feet to 2 feet) to minimize additional regrading costs.
Integrate with TOD: Coordinate with the broader development plan, including
connectivity to public amenities and the Medical Center.
Demonstrate Economic Viability: Provide a cost-effective, sustainable alternative to
traditional grey infrastructure while offering community and environmental benefits.
3. Site Context and Soil Analysis
3.1. Overview of the 39Acre Site
The 39acre site is owned by the Mobile Housing Authority and has been selected for
redevelopment due to its strategic location near key public assets. The site consists of a mix of
developable land—characterized by favorable BuC soils—and an adjacent cityowned park. The
edible rain garden system will be implemented only on the developable area.
3.2. Natural Topography and Existing Grading
The site naturally slopes from an elevation of approximately 30 feet at the northern boundary
down to 2 feet near Three Mile Creek. This gradual slope not only aids natural drainage but also
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
4
minimizes the need for extensive regrading. The design takes full advantage of this feature to
reduce costs and enhance stormwater infiltration.
3.3. Soil Resource Analysis (Focus on BuC Soils)
According to the NRCS soil survey for Mobile County (see “MobileCountySoilReport2017.pdf
available at https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/main/soils/health/), the BuC
(BenndaleUrban land complex) is the predominant soil type on the developable portion of the
site. Key properties include:
Drainage: Welldrained conditions suitable for rapid infiltration.
Saturated Hydraulic Conductivity (Ksat): Approximately 0.60 to 2.00 inches per hour,
indicating high permeability.
Water Table Depth: Typically more than 80 inches, ensuring that temporary water
retention does not result in prolonged saturation.
Soil Texture: A fine sandy loam surface over a loam subsoil, ideal for both water
infiltration and crop cultivation.
These soil characteristics form the foundation for both the stormwater management strategy and
the edible production system.
4. Stormwater Management and Overflow Design
4.1. Current Stormwater Challenges in Mobile
Mobile experiences heavy rainfall—averaging around 66 inches annually—which leads to
substantial stormwater runoff from impervious surfaces such as roofs, parking lots, and paved
streets. Traditionally, this runoff is managed using grey infrastructure (e.g., large pipes, detention
basins) that are costly to install and maintain. Excess runoff contributes to flooding, particularly in
the Three Mile Creek area, exacerbating existing municipal challenges.
4.2. Design of a Central Drainage Pond and Integrated Rain Garden
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
5
To address these issues, our design proposes a two-part solution:
1. Central Drainage Pond:
A single, centrally located pond (or at most two ponds across the 39-acre site) will
serve as the primary retention facility.
The pond is engineered to capture runoff from all impervious surfaces on the
developable area and include a regulated overflow system that safely diverts
excess water into the city’s drainage system or directly to Three Mile Creek
without increasing its current flow.
The pond will also be designed to support aquaculture (e.g., catfish stocking) as
an added function to control mosquito larvae and potentially generate local
protein.
2. Integrated Edible Rain Gardens:
Surrounding the central pond, edible rain gardens will be established to provide
additional infiltration capacity and food production.
Each quadruplex is allocated a designated rain garden area that meets both
stormwater and caloric production requirements.
4.3. Overflow Management: Calculations and Safety Considerations
Detailed calculations (see Technical Appendix Section 9.1) address:
Runoff Generation:
For example, a 1inch rainstorm on a 1,700sqft roof produces approximately 1,059 gallons
of runoff.
Infiltration Capacity:
With an average Ksat of 1 inch per hour in BuC soils, the design aims for complete
infiltration within 24 hours.
Overflow Control:
A regulated overflow system (using a standpipe or weir) is incorporated into the central
pond to safely divert excess water. This system is designed so that even under extreme
rainfall events, the additional runoff does not overload Three Mile Creek’s existing
drainage capacity.
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
6
Table 1: Stormwater Volume and Infiltration Requirements
Impervious
Surface
Approximate Area
(sq ft)
Runoff per 1" Rain
(gallons)
Notes
Roof (per
quadruplex)
1,700
~1,059
1,700 × 1 × 0.623
Parking &
Pavement*
Variable
Calculated
separately
Based on percentage of
impervious area
Total (Estimated)
3,000–4,000
Aggregated from all surfaces
per quadruplex
*Values for parking and paved areas are derived from site-specific assessments.
5. Edible Rain Garden Design for Food Production
5.1. Caloric Yield Objectives and Target Outputs
Based on an average tenant consuming 2,000 calories daily, the edible component is designed
to produce approximately 600 calories per day per resident (30% of total caloric intake). For a
quadruplex with 8 residents, the total daily yield target is approximately 4,800 calories.
5.2. Crop Selection, Yield Data, and Companion Planting Strategies
Crop selection focuses on high-yield, calorie-dense staples that are familiar to local residents.
Recommended crops include:
Potatoes/Sweet Potatoes:
Yield: Approximately 20,000–25,000 pounds per acre.
Caloric Value: ~350 calories per pound.
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
7
Familiarity: Widely consumed and versatile in local cuisine.
Corn:
A staple crop with extensive culinary uses.
Yield data to be referenced from regional studies.
Legumes (Beans):
Provide both calories and protein.
Contribute to soil nitrogen fixation.
Complementary Crops:
Companion planting strategies include interplanting with onions or garlic to deter
pests and using nitrogen-fixing plants to reduce fertilizer needs.
Detailed companion planting schemas will be provided to illustrate optimal crop arrangements
that reduce labor and maximize yield. These strategies are informed by research from regional
agricultural institutions (e.g., Auburn University).
Figure 2 (Placeholder): A diagram illustrating a sample companion planting layout, showing crop
rotations and intercropping patterns.
5.3. Area Requirements: Balancing Infiltration and Food Production
The edible rain garden must satisfy two critical functions:
1. Infiltration:
Based on BuC soil parameters, approximately 300–400 sq ft per quadruplex is
needed solely for stormwater infiltration.
2. Food Production:
Yield calculations suggest that an additional 700–1,100 sq ft is required to meet
the daily caloric target of 4,800 calories per quadruplex.
Thus, the recommended total area for the integrated edible rain garden per quadruplex is
between 1,000 and 1,500 sq ft.
Table 2: Area Requirement Comparison
Function
Area Required per Quadruplex (sq ft)
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
8
Stormwater Infiltration
300–400
Food Production
700–1,100
Total Combined Area
1,000–1,500
6. Integration with Broader Development Goals
6.1. Transit-Oriented Development and Connectivity
Serenity Village is embedded within a broader TOD framework designed to:
Enhance Connectivity:
A water taxi system along Three Mile Creek and road-based transit options
connect the development to the nearby Medical Center.
Leverage Existing Public Assets:
Although the adjacent city park is managed separately, its proximity adds to the
overall quality of the neighborhood.
Support Sustainable Mobility:
Reducing the need for private vehicles while increasing pedestrian-friendly
spaces.
6.2. Economic Benefits and Cost Savings
The integrated green infrastructure offers several cost-saving advantages:
Lower Construction Costs:
Reduced need for extensive piping, excavation, and detention basin construction.
Maintenance Savings:
Natural infiltration systems require less routine maintenance than mechanical grey
systems.
Municipal Benefits:
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
9
By reducing runoff and flood risks, the system lowers the City of Mobile’s flood
control expenditures.
Reuse of Existing Grading:
The natural slope minimizes additional earthwork costs.
Table 3: Economic Cost Comparison
Component
Proposed Green Infrastructure
Stormwater Piping
Reduced diameter; lower material
cost
Excavation/Grading
Minimal; leverages natural slope
Detention Basin
Distributed system; lower cumulative
cost
Overall Savings
Estimated 25–50% reduction in total
costs
6.3. Potential Job Creation and Community Empowerment
The system provides ancillary community benefits:
Employment Opportunities:
Potential roles in garden maintenance and aquaculture (e.g., for foster youth
transitioning out of care).
Local Economic Revitalization:
Increased local activity from food truck operations, produce sales, and
complementary services.
Community Training:
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
10
Opportunities for residents to learn sustainable practices, fostering a sense of
ownership and long-term community stability.
7. Microclimate, Shade, and Passive Cooling Strategies
7.1. Addressing Mobile’s Climate
Mobile’s hot, humid conditions necessitate strategies to
improve microclimate:
Temporary Shade Structures:
Deploy shade sails or retractable canopies
during the hottest months.
Permanent Shade via Tree Planting:
Plant fast-growing, potentially fruit-bearing
trees around the garden perimeter to create natural
canopies.
Strategic Site Layout:
Position sensitive crop zones in naturally cooler, shaded areas of the site.
7.2. Passive Cooling and Shade Design Proposals
Additional passive cooling measures include:
Vegetative Buffers:
Dense plantings around the perimeter can lower ambient temperatures through
evapotranspiration.
Water Feature Benefits:
A gently flowing central drainage pond can have a localized cooling effect.
Optimized Orientation:
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
11
Design the garden layout to minimize direct sun exposure during peak heat
periods.
Figure 3 (Placeholder): Schematic diagram showing the proposed placement of shade sails, tree
buffers, and vegetative cover to achieve passive cooling.
8. Economic Impact and Cost-Savings Analysis
8.1. Comparison: Grey vs. Green Infrastructure
Green infrastructure reduces overall costs by:
Material and Installation Savings:
Lower reliance on expensive concrete, large-diameter pipes, and deep
excavation.
Reduced Maintenance Expenses:
Natural systems tend to require less frequent maintenance compared to
mechanical systems.
Long-Term Cost Benefits:
Lifecycle savings of 25–50% are achievable based on published studies.
8.2. Reuse of Existing Grading
The site's natural gradient—from 30 feet at the northern edge to 2 feet near the creek—minimizes
the need for additional regrading, thereby reducing construction costs and preserving existing
green space.
8.3. Broader Municipal Savings
For the City of Mobile, the system promises:
Lower Flood Control Costs:
Reduced runoff minimizes the burden on municipal drainage systems.
Potential Incentives:
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
12
Eligibility for stormwater fee credits and green infrastructure grants.
Table 4: Municipal and Developer Savings Summary
Category
Expected Savings/Advantages
Material Cost Savings
Up to 25–50% reduction versus conventional systems
Reduced Excavation/Grading
Lower cost by leveraging existing site slopes
Lower Maintenance
Less frequent upkeep compared to mechanical
systems
Municipal Flood Control Costs
Reduced burden on city infrastructure
Enhanced Property Value
Improved aesthetics and multifunctionality
9. Technical Appendix
This section provides detailed technical information supporting the design. It includes
step-by-step calculations, yield estimates, and schematic diagrams.
9.1. Stormwater Volume and Infiltration Calculations
9.1.1. Runoff Generation from Impervious Surfaces
For a 1inch rainstorm:
Roof Calculation:
Runoff (gallons)=Area (sq ft)×Rainfall (in)×0.623\text{Runoff (gallons)} = \text{Area (sq ft)}
\times \text{Rainfall (in)} \times 0.623Runoff (gallons)=Area (sq ft)×Rainfall (in)×0.623
For a 1,700sqft roof:
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
13
1,700×1×0.623≈1,059 gallons1,700 \times 1 \times 0.623 \approx 1,059 \text{
gallons}1,700×1×0.623≈1,059 gallons
Additional Impervious Areas:
Parking lots and paved walkways are similarly calculated based on their area and
impervious fraction.
9.1.2. Infiltration Capacity of BuC Soils
Given:
Ksat (average): ~1 inch per hour
Drawdown Target: 24 hours
The infiltration area AiA_iAi required is estimated as:
Ai≈Runoff VolumeKsat×Drawdown Time×0.623A_i \approx \frac{\text{Runoff Volume}}{\text{Ksat}
\times \text{Drawdown Time} \times 0.623}Ai ≈Ksat×Drawdown Time×0.623Runoff Volume
For the roof runoff:
Ai≈1,0591×24×0.623≈70 sq ft per roofA_i \approx \frac{1,059}{1 \times 24 \times 0.623} \approx 70
\text{ sq ft per roof}Ai ≈1×24×0.6231,059 ≈70 sq ft per roof
Aggregated across all impervious surfaces, this yields roughly 300–400 sq ft per quadruplex
dedicated solely to infiltration.
Table 5: Example Runoff and Infiltration Calculations
Surface Type
Area (sq ft)
Runoff per 1" Rain
(gallons)
Infiltration Area Needed (sq
ft)
Roof
1,700
~1,059
~70
Parking &
Walkways
2,500*
~1,558
~105*
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
14
Total (Estimate)
~2,617
300–400 (aggregate
estimate)
*Values for parking are illustrative and will be refined based on site-specific impervious fractions.
9.2. Caloric Production and Yield Estimates
9.2.1. Caloric Requirement
For a quadruplex with 8 residents:
8×600 cal/day=4,800 calories/day8 \times 600 \text{ cal/day} = 4,800 \text{ calories/day}8×600
cal/day=4,800 calories/day
9.2.2. Crop Yield Conversion
Using published yield data for the Mobile region:
Potatoes:
Yield: 20,000–25,000 lb/acre
One acre = 43,560 sq ft, so yield ≈ 0.5–0.6 lb/sq ft
Caloric content: ~350 cal/lb
Therefore, per square foot yield ≈ 175–210 cal
Sweet Potatoes:
Similar yield estimates as potatoes; slight differences in caloric density
Corn:
Yields vary; assume published regional data for a conservative estimate
Legumes:
Lower caloric density but beneficial for protein and soil health
9.2.3. Total Area Requirement
For a combined target of 4,800 calories/day:
Assume an average of 200 calories per sq ft from a mix of crops:
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
15
4,800 calories200 cal/sq ft=24 sq ft\frac{4,800 \text{ calories}}{200 \text{ cal/sq ft}} = 24 \text{ sq
ft}200 cal/sq ft4,800 calories =24 sq ft
This is a theoretical minimum for pure crop production; however, practical field conditions
(spacing, intercropping, loss factors) require scaling up. Detailed yield conversion tables (see
Appendix A) indicate that approximately 700–1,100 sq ft is needed for food production per
quadruplex. When combined with the infiltration area, the total becomes roughly 1,000–1,500 sq
ft per quadruplex.
Table 6: Crop Yield and Caloric Conversion (per sq ft)
Crop
Yield (lb/sq ft)
Calories per lb
Calories per sq ft (Estimate)
Potatoes
0.5 – 0.6
350
175 – 210
Sweet
Potatoes
0.5 – 0.6
360
180 – 216
Corn (average)
~0.4
350
~140
Beans
~0.3
340
~102
Using a diversified mix can average out to about 200 cal/sq ft under optimal conditions.
9.3. Schematic Diagrams, Tables, and MATLAB Plot Excerpts
The following schematic diagrams and plots are recommended for inclusion:
Figure 1: Central Drainage Pond and Integrated Edible Rain Garden Layout
– A MATLAB-generated plot showing site contours, drainage flow paths, and designated
garden zones.
Figure 2: Companion Planting Layout
– A detailed schematic diagram showing intercropping arrangements, rotation schedules,
and spatial distribution.
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
16
Figure 3: Shade and Passive Cooling Schematic
– Diagrams illustrating the placement of shade sails, tree buffers, and vegetative cover.
MATLAB Plot Excerpts:
– Graphs of runoff volume versus infiltration area and caloric yield versus garden area,
demonstrating the intersecting design criteria.
Table 7: Summary of Technical Assumptions and Parameters
Parameter
Value/Range
Source/Assumption
Average Roof Area per
Quadruplex
~1,700 sq ft
Design Estimate
Ksat for BuC Soils
0.60 – 2.00 in/hr (avg. ~1)
NRCS Soil Survey
Rainfall (Design Storm)
1 inch per event
Standard design parameter
Daily Caloric Target per
Resident
600 cal/day (30% of 2,000)
USDA dietary guidelines
(assumed)
Edible Production Area
Needed
700–1,100 sq ft per
quadruplex
Derived from yield data (see
Table 6)
Total Combined Garden Area
1,000–1,500 sq ft per
quadruplex
Infiltration + Production
10. Conclusions and Recommendations
10.1. Summary of Findings
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
17
The integrated design for Serenity Village demonstrates that:
A centrally located drainage pond, combined with strategically placed edible rain
gardens, effectively manages stormwater on a 39acre site while ensuring that Three Mile
Creek’s flow remains unchanged.
Allocating 1,000–1,500 sq ft per quadruplex for the integrated system can produce the
target 4,800 calories per day for eight residents, while also providing sufficient infiltration
capacity.
The natural site grading and BuC soil conditions minimize additional regrading, reducing
both construction and long-term maintenance costs.
Incorporating shade and passive cooling strategies addresses Mobile’s challenging
climate, improving both resident comfort and crop yield.
The system not only lowers development and municipal costs but also enhances
community connectivity through its alignment with TOD principles, and it offers potential,
though modest, employment opportunities for vulnerable populations.
10.2. Recommendations
1. Implement the Integrated System:
Proceed with the design of a central drainage pond integrated with edible rain
gardens on the developable portion of the site.
2. Conduct a Detailed Engineering Review:
Collaborate with local engineering and agricultural experts to refine the runoff,
infiltration, and yield calculations.
3. Pilot the System:
Establish a pilot project within Serenity Village to validate assumptions, optimize
companion planting schemas, and train local community members.
4. Align with TOD Goals:
Ensure that the rain garden system is coordinated with the broader
Transit-Oriented Development strategy and municipal drainage requirements.
5. Plan for Future Upgrades:
Design the system with flexibility for the integration of real-time IoT monitoring,
advanced aquaculture controls, and evolving climate adaptation strategies.
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
18
11. References and Appendices
References
1. U.S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resources Conservation Service. “Soil Health.
Available at:
https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/main/soils/health/
(Accessed: February 2025)
2. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. “Green Infrastructure.” Available at:
https://www.epa.gov/green-infrastructure
(Accessed: February 2025)
3. U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. “Housing Choice Voucher (HCV)
Program FYI.” Available at:
https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/public_indian_housing/programs/hcv/fyi
(Accessed: February 2025)
4. ASTM International. “ASTM E2774-17: Guidelines for Sustainable Rainwater Infiltration
Systems.” Available at:
https://www.astm.org/Standards/E2774.htm
(Accessed: February 2025)
5. Additional peer-reviewed literature and regional agricultural yield data from Auburn
University and the University of Alabama can be referenced via:
https://www.ag.auburn.edu/ and https://www.uaex.uada.edu/
(Accessed: February 2025)
Appendices
Appendix A: Detailed Yield and Caloric Conversion Tables
Table A1: Yield Data and Caloric Conversion for Key Crops
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
19
Crop
Yield
(lb/acre)
Yield (lb/sq
ft)
Caloric Content
(cal/lb)
Estimated Calories per
sq ft
Potatoes
20,000 –
25,000
0.46 – 0.57
350
161 – 200
Sweet
Potatoes
20,000 –
25,000
0.46 – 0.57
360
166 – 205
Corn
15,000 –
18,000
0.34 – 0.41
350
119 – 144
Beans (Dry)
8,000 –
10,000
0.18 – 0.23
340
61 – 78
*Notes:
– Yield values have been converted from per-acre values assuming 43,560 sq ft per acre.
– These tables use average values from regional agricultural studies. Detailed sources are
available from Auburn University’s College of Agriculture and the University of Alabama
Extension.
Appendix B: Full Stormwater Volume and Infiltration Calculation Sheets
Calculation Example for a Quadruplex Roof:
1. Roof Runoff Calculation:
Roof Area = 1,700 sq ft
Rainfall Depth = 1 inch
Conversion Factor = 0.623 (gallons/sq ft/inch)
Runoff=1,700×1×0.623≈1,059 gallons\text{Runoff} = 1,700 \times 1 \times 0.623
\approx 1,059 \text{ gallons}Runoff=1,700×1×0.623≈1,059 gallons
2. Infiltration Area Calculation:
Target: Infiltrate 1,059 gallons within 24 hours
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
20
Ksat (BuC soils) ≈ 1 in/hr
Using the formula:
Ai=RunoffKsat×Time×0.623A_i = \frac{\text{Runoff}}{\text{Ksat} \times \text{Time}
\times 0.623}Ai =Ksat×Time×0.623Runoff Ai≈1,0591×24×0.623≈70 sq ftA_i \approx
\frac{1,059}{1 \times 24 \times 0.623} \approx 70 \text{ sq ft}Ai ≈1×24×0.6231,059 ≈70
sq ft
3. Aggregated Impervious Areas:
Include additional runoff from parking and walkways. Example: 2,500 sq ft of
parking yields:
Runoff≈2,500×1×0.623≈1,558 gallons\text{Runoff} \approx 2,500 \times 1 \times
0.623 \approx 1,558 \text{ gallons}Runoff≈2,500×1×0.623≈1,558 gallons
Total runoff per quadruplex (roof + parking) may be estimated at 2,617 gallons.
Total infiltration area then scales to approximately 300–400 sq ft after safety
factors are applied.
Detailed worksheets and step-by-step calculations for all impervious surfaces are provided in the
attached calculation sheets (to be appended as PDF documents in the final print version).
Appendix C: Schematic Diagrams and MATLAB Plot Excerpts
Figure C1: Central Drainage Pond Layout
A diagram showing the central pond dimensions, overflow standpipe, and integration with
adjacent edible rain gardens.
Suggested MATLAB plot parameters: Contour lines based on site elevation (30 ft to 2 ft),
water flow vectors, and designated garden zones.
Figure C2: Companion Planting Schematic
A detailed layout of crop rows and intercropping patterns, illustrating recommended
spacing and crop rotation schedules.
Figure C3: Shade and Passive Cooling Diagram
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
21
Illustrates proposed locations for shade sails, fast-growing tree buffers, and vegetative
barriers to optimize microclimate.
Note: Actual images and MATLAB-generated plots are to be created by the engineering team;
these descriptions serve as guidelines for the final graphical assets.
Appendix D: Economic Analysis Tables and Cost Comparison Breakdown
Table D1: Cost Comparison – Grey Infrastructure vs. Green Infrastructure
Cost
Component
Grey Infrastructure
(Estimated)
Green Infrastructure
(Proposed)
Source/Assumption
Stormwater
Piping
$75 per linear foot
20–25% lower due to
reduced diameter
Industry cost data; local
contractor estimates
Excavation and
Grading
Extensive, high
cost
Minimal; reuse of
existing grading
Engineering estimates
based on site conditions
Detention Basin
Construction
Up to $200,000+
Distributed across
smaller, modular
systems
Published studies on green
infrastructure
Maintenance
(Annual)
High (regular
cleaning, repairs)
Lower (natural systems
require minimal
upkeep)
Comparative lifecycle cost
studies
Total Estimated
Savings
25–50% reduction in
capital and
maintenance costs
Based on multi-study
analysis from EPA and
USDA
Table D2: Projected Cost Savings for the City of Mobile
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com
Serenity Village at Three Mile Creek
22
Expense Category
Conventional
Cost
Green Infrastructure
Cost
Estimated Municipal
Savings (%)
Flood Control
Upgrades
High
(multi-million)
Significantly reduced
25–40%
Stormwater Fee
Credits
Standard rates
Reduced rates
possible
Dependent on local policy
Appendix E: Additional Technical Notes and Assumptions
General Assumptions:
Rainfall Data: Based on Mobile’s average annual rainfall of 66 inches, with design storms
of 1 inch used for calculations.
Soil Properties: BuC soils have an average Ksat of approximately 1 inch per hour and a
deep water table (>80 inches).
Caloric Requirements: Assumes an average adult daily caloric intake of 2,000 calories,
with a 30% contribution from on-site production.
Crop Yield Data: Derived from published regional agricultural research from Auburn
University and the University of Alabama.
Site Grading: Natural slope from 30 feet at the northern edge to 2 feet at the creek is
preserved as much as possible.
Economic Parameters: Cost comparisons use industry averages and local contractor
estimates; actual costs may vary.
Overflow Design: The regulated overflow system is modeled on existing Mobile drainage
designs and municipal guidelines.
These technical notes are intended to guide further detailed engineering studies and should be
revisited once site-specific data are collected.
________________________________________________
© North Star Group, Inc. 2024 All rights reserved.
19901 Quail Circle
Fairhope AL 36532
701-770-9118
michaelh@nsgia.com